I said last week that I expected to have Assassin’s Guild rules written by today. Unfortunately there was a bit of a delay as there were a couple points I was unhappy with, namely Profile.
Speaking of which, I mentioned Profile a lot while writing this blog, but I never really got around to explaining it in any particular dept. So today I decided to give you a look at it.
From a concept standpoint Profile relates to the attention you got when committing an assassination. From a gameplay point of view was it did was that once you reached a certain amount you would be punished, specifically I was considering that you would lose a “Bounty token”, meaning you would be set back by one assassination.
Now, this was supposed to be a way to force the players to use a larger variety of tactics in order to avoid getting their Profile too high. The problem however was that currently the game lacks any significant ways to interact with it. Specifically, there are 2 symmetrical cards and one (expensive) weapon that allows players to mess with Profile at all, none of which is particularly interesting.
I seriously considered dropping it altogether, but by doing so I would risk the game getting too shallow, especially since it was one of the few ways players could mess with each other without me feeling it would be too unfair.
Eventually I came to the decision of turning Profile into more of a resource. By itself this won’t change the game for the players, in fact it doesn’t require rule changes at all, but it allows a bigger variety on the design of, specifically, cards.
The reason there are so few cards right now is that there were very few I felt would be sufficiently balanced. However it occurred to me that I can get away with much more varied, and powerful, cards if I associate a Profile penalty to their use.
Ultimately what all of this means is that I expect the prototype to contain a larger variety of cards (and possibly, weapons) than the ones I mentioned previously.
On another note, I feel the card “Switch” needs to be cut from the game, as it would likely discourage the acquisition of the most expensive weapons, especially if I tried to penalize its use in some way.
Tuesday, 23 February 2010
Tuesday, 16 February 2010
Card carrying villain
Cards and weapons in Assassin’s Guild will be a major factor in both making the game interesting and replayable, as they should become a key factor in many strategies.
Therefore, today I’ve decided to give you a look on the cards and weapons I have in mind for Assassin’s Guild.
Cards:
Name: Double Pace
Effect: Player can take two Actions this turn.
Comments: Prior to the inclusion of the concept of an “Action” this card simply allowed the player to move twice in the same turn. It still fulfils that role, but is far more versatile now.
Name: Pickpocket
Effect: Player receives two Gold
Comments: The reason the player only gets two Gold is because I feared that if he got more it could give him a huge card advantage. Although if playtesting eventually shows this not to be an issue it’s possible that it gets changed into three.
Name: Disguise
Effect: Player loses two Profile
Comments: This is mostly so players have a way to control their profile without resorting to specific weapons all the time.
Name: Anonymous tip
Effect: Target player receives two Profile
Comments: For a significant amount time this was the only card that actually allowed one player to affect another. This led to the creation of more cards to go with the prototype as I feared the game would not have enough player interaction otherwise, making it too reliant on luck.
Name: Switch
Effect: Switch one of your weapons with that of target player.
Comments: This is one of the reasons I was happy with the inclusion of “Actions”, as it meant this card became viable. I’m sure it can lead into some interesting situations.
Name: Decoy
Effect: Move target VIP to a random unoccupied VIP position
Comments: The reason the VIP is moved to a random position is simply so a player can’t head to a different location than everyone else and then uses the card to steal the kill.
Several other cards were considered, yet at this point these are the ones I’m happier with.
Weapons:
Name: Dagger
Range: 1
Cost: 1
Profile: 2
Name: Flintlock Pistol
Range: 3
Cost: 2
Profile: 2
Name: Rifle
Range: 5
Cost: 4
Profile: 2
Name: Poisoned Dart
Range: 3
Cost: 4
Profile: 1
As of right now, weapons are fairly standard affairs. The idea is simply to provide one weapon for each standard range along with a low profile one.
In other news, the concept for Assassin’s Guild is pretty much final as of now. I expect to have the full rules written down and ready for playtesting by next week.
Therefore, today I’ve decided to give you a look on the cards and weapons I have in mind for Assassin’s Guild.
Cards:
Name: Double Pace
Effect: Player can take two Actions this turn.
Comments: Prior to the inclusion of the concept of an “Action” this card simply allowed the player to move twice in the same turn. It still fulfils that role, but is far more versatile now.
Name: Pickpocket
Effect: Player receives two Gold
Comments: The reason the player only gets two Gold is because I feared that if he got more it could give him a huge card advantage. Although if playtesting eventually shows this not to be an issue it’s possible that it gets changed into three.
Name: Disguise
Effect: Player loses two Profile
Comments: This is mostly so players have a way to control their profile without resorting to specific weapons all the time.
Name: Anonymous tip
Effect: Target player receives two Profile
Comments: For a significant amount time this was the only card that actually allowed one player to affect another. This led to the creation of more cards to go with the prototype as I feared the game would not have enough player interaction otherwise, making it too reliant on luck.
Name: Switch
Effect: Switch one of your weapons with that of target player.
Comments: This is one of the reasons I was happy with the inclusion of “Actions”, as it meant this card became viable. I’m sure it can lead into some interesting situations.
Name: Decoy
Effect: Move target VIP to a random unoccupied VIP position
Comments: The reason the VIP is moved to a random position is simply so a player can’t head to a different location than everyone else and then uses the card to steal the kill.
Several other cards were considered, yet at this point these are the ones I’m happier with.
Weapons:
Name: Dagger
Range: 1
Cost: 1
Profile: 2
Name: Flintlock Pistol
Range: 3
Cost: 2
Profile: 2
Name: Rifle
Range: 5
Cost: 4
Profile: 2
Name: Poisoned Dart
Range: 3
Cost: 4
Profile: 1
As of right now, weapons are fairly standard affairs. The idea is simply to provide one weapon for each standard range along with a low profile one.
In other news, the concept for Assassin’s Guild is pretty much final as of now. I expect to have the full rules written down and ready for playtesting by next week.
Tuesday, 9 February 2010
About time
When creating the current version of Assassin’s Guild, I’ve envisioned players at the start of each game and after each kill carefully pondering what equipment they would be getting in preparation for their next kill. So it always nagged me a bit that, so far, they could simply approach the target, buy the best gun for the job then and there, and collect the bounty.
The other day I was considering the best way for card timing to work. Mostly because using cards “at any time during your turn” felt like it could be subject to some abuse with some of the cards I had planned.
Eventually I ruled that cards could be played during your turn “before or after and Action”.
Curiously, this new wording provided me with an answer to several of my concerns regarding the game, and allowed me to work around the “nags” mentioned at the start of this post. All I would needed to do was to define exactly what an “Action” was and how many you could take during your turn.
Part of the reason why I never ruled that you couldn’t move and assassinate a VIP on the same was not so much because it felt like a somewhat unnecessary delay, but mostly because it never really solved my main nag: Players not needing to get a weapon until they were in range of their target.
Previously I had toyed with the idea of including shops, or otherwise limiting where and when players could buy weapons or cards, but I had not found one that wouldn’t feel either artificially arbitrary or delay the game significantly.
Which is where Actions come in.
An Action is a simple to understand and somewhat organic concept: It’s an event that takes time to execute. So it makes sense that during a turn you’re limited to a certain number of actions.
With that in mind it makes sense that the most crucial gameplay events be considered Actions. In this case I deemed as an Action “Move”, “Assassinate”, and “Shop”.
I also had to decide how many Actions one could take in a single turn. On first instance, the Player can make one Action per turn.
This decision should solve several problems I had with the game. Namely, player order should matter less since committing an assassination will slow a Player down while they acquire new weapons, effectively denying any advantage Player order might have given him.
On the matter of players only needing to buy weapons when in range, the compromise is actually fairly interesting. Players can still do that, but will be set back by at least a turn, a turn which they may not have. So while doing so is still an option, it’s a much more complex one.
The other day I was considering the best way for card timing to work. Mostly because using cards “at any time during your turn” felt like it could be subject to some abuse with some of the cards I had planned.
Eventually I ruled that cards could be played during your turn “before or after and Action”.
Curiously, this new wording provided me with an answer to several of my concerns regarding the game, and allowed me to work around the “nags” mentioned at the start of this post. All I would needed to do was to define exactly what an “Action” was and how many you could take during your turn.
Part of the reason why I never ruled that you couldn’t move and assassinate a VIP on the same was not so much because it felt like a somewhat unnecessary delay, but mostly because it never really solved my main nag: Players not needing to get a weapon until they were in range of their target.
Previously I had toyed with the idea of including shops, or otherwise limiting where and when players could buy weapons or cards, but I had not found one that wouldn’t feel either artificially arbitrary or delay the game significantly.
Which is where Actions come in.
An Action is a simple to understand and somewhat organic concept: It’s an event that takes time to execute. So it makes sense that during a turn you’re limited to a certain number of actions.
With that in mind it makes sense that the most crucial gameplay events be considered Actions. In this case I deemed as an Action “Move”, “Assassinate”, and “Shop”.
I also had to decide how many Actions one could take in a single turn. On first instance, the Player can make one Action per turn.
This decision should solve several problems I had with the game. Namely, player order should matter less since committing an assassination will slow a Player down while they acquire new weapons, effectively denying any advantage Player order might have given him.
On the matter of players only needing to buy weapons when in range, the compromise is actually fairly interesting. Players can still do that, but will be set back by at least a turn, a turn which they may not have. So while doing so is still an option, it’s a much more complex one.
Tuesday, 2 February 2010
The value of life
Over the past week, most of Assassin’s Guild development has been focused on the weapons. Specifically, what they could do and how much they would cost.
Since early in the development of the current version of the game, I wanted a short, medium, and long range weapon, as well as a low profile one (possibly medium range). These would be discarded after use (imagine it as running out of ammo).
Now, initially I had thought that the three core guns would cost, respectively, 1, 2, and 3 gold. 3 Gold would also be your starting money and the amount you received every time you made an assassination.
It seemed to me that a problem might emerge from these numbers. Namely, it could be very tempting for players to stick to the long range weapon and ignore both the other weapons and cards (right now intended to cost 1 Gold each), and I feared that improving the existing weapons/cards might cause them to become game breaking.
Fortunately in this case there is a fairly obvious solution: Make the long ranged weapon cost 4 instead of 3.
I like this solution for several reasons, the lesser of which is its original goal of making players less relying on the weapon. The main reason I like this solution is that leaves players with a bit extra money at both game and after each assassination, which means they might be tempted to invest in cards and try the various weapons.
On bit more advanced part of the design, I wanted the short ranged weapon to be a dagger. However daggers don’t really need ammo so maybe you shouldn’t discard it after use.
I kind of liked this idea, but the problem emerged that the dagger could be too good for its 1 Gold cost. This was particularly problematic at the current ranges: Short range is 1 Space, Medium 3, and Long 5. The dagger risked being too good.
Eventually this point was resolved while considering another possible feature, which was…
… The ability of players to kill one another.
Again, I liked this idea. It also helped “balance” the slight advantage the first players might get on account of later players being able to set them back.
The mechanics of this would be fairly simple. A player would assassinate the other the same way they would for a VIP, and get Profile but no Money. The assassinated player would probably just go back to the game start position (other effects were considered, like reducing profile, but I suspect that would be open to abuse and we might end up with players asking to be killed).
The problem here is that it would be fairly easy for a player to get stuck with no weapons or money. So I thought: “I know! I’ll just give everyone a dagger. That way I don’t have to worry about the dagger being too cheap”.
Yeah… There are just a couple tiny problems…
The dagger would be far too powerful and the players could end up far too rich.
You see, the reason I maintained such small ranges for the weapons so far is that I expected the players to be racing fairly close together, so the couple moves the players could save by having a weapon with a slightly longer range might be enough to justify the investment.
However the moment you could send the other players back to the start, means that the spatial gap could easily increase by several turns, giving enough time for the player to do the assassination with the close range, but free and eternal, dagger. This would be the more evident the fewer players there would be.
Eventually I decided that the ability to kill other players and the idea of an inexhaustible dagger simply had to go.
On a bit of a side note, I realize that under the current rules it is still possible for a player to get stuck without money or weapons, simply by investing all its money on cards. This means that I’ll probably need to include the rather artificial ruling that “players must carry a weapon, or enough money to acquire one, at all times".
Since early in the development of the current version of the game, I wanted a short, medium, and long range weapon, as well as a low profile one (possibly medium range). These would be discarded after use (imagine it as running out of ammo).
Now, initially I had thought that the three core guns would cost, respectively, 1, 2, and 3 gold. 3 Gold would also be your starting money and the amount you received every time you made an assassination.
It seemed to me that a problem might emerge from these numbers. Namely, it could be very tempting for players to stick to the long range weapon and ignore both the other weapons and cards (right now intended to cost 1 Gold each), and I feared that improving the existing weapons/cards might cause them to become game breaking.
Fortunately in this case there is a fairly obvious solution: Make the long ranged weapon cost 4 instead of 3.
I like this solution for several reasons, the lesser of which is its original goal of making players less relying on the weapon. The main reason I like this solution is that leaves players with a bit extra money at both game and after each assassination, which means they might be tempted to invest in cards and try the various weapons.
On bit more advanced part of the design, I wanted the short ranged weapon to be a dagger. However daggers don’t really need ammo so maybe you shouldn’t discard it after use.
I kind of liked this idea, but the problem emerged that the dagger could be too good for its 1 Gold cost. This was particularly problematic at the current ranges: Short range is 1 Space, Medium 3, and Long 5. The dagger risked being too good.
Eventually this point was resolved while considering another possible feature, which was…
… The ability of players to kill one another.
Again, I liked this idea. It also helped “balance” the slight advantage the first players might get on account of later players being able to set them back.
The mechanics of this would be fairly simple. A player would assassinate the other the same way they would for a VIP, and get Profile but no Money. The assassinated player would probably just go back to the game start position (other effects were considered, like reducing profile, but I suspect that would be open to abuse and we might end up with players asking to be killed).
The problem here is that it would be fairly easy for a player to get stuck with no weapons or money. So I thought: “I know! I’ll just give everyone a dagger. That way I don’t have to worry about the dagger being too cheap”.
Yeah… There are just a couple tiny problems…
The dagger would be far too powerful and the players could end up far too rich.
You see, the reason I maintained such small ranges for the weapons so far is that I expected the players to be racing fairly close together, so the couple moves the players could save by having a weapon with a slightly longer range might be enough to justify the investment.
However the moment you could send the other players back to the start, means that the spatial gap could easily increase by several turns, giving enough time for the player to do the assassination with the close range, but free and eternal, dagger. This would be the more evident the fewer players there would be.
Eventually I decided that the ability to kill other players and the idea of an inexhaustible dagger simply had to go.
On a bit of a side note, I realize that under the current rules it is still possible for a player to get stuck without money or weapons, simply by investing all its money on cards. This means that I’ll probably need to include the rather artificial ruling that “players must carry a weapon, or enough money to acquire one, at all times".
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)