Tuesday, 12 January 2010

Can I kill you now?

Development of Assassin’s Guild has come across two main issues recently.

The first, and possibly more significant one, is card timing. I mentioned previously that I was considering ruling that at the end of a player’s move, players take turns playing cards.
The problem here is the card’s effect timing. First I was considering a “last in first out” system, i.e. when multiple cards are played, the last one played is the first one to take effect. The main advantage of this is that it allows the players to respond to those who had their turn before them.
However this becomes an issue with assassination cards, since it means that once one is used, every other card played before with the same would be useless, essentially nullifying all the combos and deception I was expecting the game to be about.

The obvious solution would be use a different timing for assassination cards. But personally I’m not too fond of the idea since it adds what seems to be an arbitrary rule.

A variation of this would be to only allow one assassination card to be played in the same round, which would seriously restrict who would be killed and by whom. Again, I’m not too fond of this idea.


The second issue isn’t something that has emerged, as something that I’m increasingly unhappy with: Board interaction.

Right now there is one action you can take on the board: move.
The game is almost entirely a card game at this point, and the board interaction itself feels rather boring and uninspired.
I have considered making some changes, like instead of each player owning several VIPs these would be shared among them. However I fear this would make it too similar to one of it’s inspirations, so I’m trying to avoid going that route.

I have not discarded the idea of turning it into a full fledged card game though (but, again, there are precedents)

No comments:

Post a Comment